Journal archive · Nasal tip · Ethnic, Asian, Middle Eastern, African and Latino rhinoplasty · Open versus closed approach · 2018
Hybrid Approach for Asian Rhinoplasty: Open Approach Without Transcolumellar Incision
Kang JG, Kwon KW, Chang J.
What this paper says
The authors describe a hybrid approach giving the exposure of open rhinoplasty without the external incision across the columella, arguing its main benefit is finer millimeter-level control rather than avoiding a scar.
Overview
Open rhinoplasty exposes the framework through a small external incision; the endonasal approach avoids that incision but gives less exposure. This article describes an approach the authors say delivers full access without the external cut, and can be scaled from limited to extensive dissection depending on the case.
Sections of note
- The hybrid approach is stated to deliver unlimited exposure and technical access, enabling all the procedures of the open approach.
- It is flexible in the extent of dissection and exposure used.
- In some cases it functions as a classic endonasal or limited access approach.
- In others it supports open structural rhinoplasty and reconstruction.
- The authors argue the benefits of the nonopen approach deserve equal attention in Asian rhinoplasty practice and in training courses.
- The stated main advantage is not sparing an incision but the ability to fine-tune changes of a few millimeters at every step.
- The abstract reports no patient numbers, outcomes, complication rates, or follow-up.
What it means for a patient
- Full access to the nasal framework does not necessarily require the small scar under the nose.
- The extent of dissection can be scaled to what the individual nose needs.
- The stated benefit is finer control during surgery, which the authors value above avoiding the scar.
- This is a technique description with no measured results, so it does not show the approach performs better.
Why this paper matters
Asian rhinoplasty has been dominated by the open approach because of the structural work involved, and this argues the same work can be done without the external incision. Training implications are the authors' explicit concern. No comparative data supports the claimed advantage.
Terms
- Transcolumellar incision: The small external cut across the strip between the nostrils used in open rhinoplasty.
- Endonasal approach: Surgery done entirely through incisions inside the nostrils.
- Open structural rhinoplasty: Taking the framework apart and rebuilding it with grafts and sutures.
- Exposure: How much of the nasal framework the surgeon can see and reach.
- Dissection: Separating tissue layers to reach the structures being operated on.
Summary written by rhinoplasty.cc from the abstract, 2026-09-09; not medical advice. The authors' own abstract follows.
From the abstract
“The hybrid approach delivers unlimited exposure and technical access, enabling all the procedures of the open approach. In addition, the hybrid approach is flexible in its extent of "dissection/ exposure" It can be more of a classic endonasal or limited access approach in some cases or open structural rhinoplasty and…”
Excerpt; the full abstract is on PubMed.
Citation
Start here
What the rhinoplasty literature says on this paper's topics, cited line by line to PubMed.
Nasal tip
200 papers on this topic.
Ethnic, Asian, Middle Eastern, African and Latino rhinoplasty
167 papers on this topic.
Open versus closed approach
57 papers on this topic.
Related papers
Same topic, 2018.
- ASJ Commentary on: The Nasal Ligaments and Tip Support in Rhinoplasty: An Anatomical StudyGruber RP, Piper M, Chang J2018PMID 29394320
- ASJ 2018PMID 29788068
- ASJ The Nasal Ligaments and Tip Support in Rhinoplasty: An Anatomical StudyDaniel RK, Palhazi P2018PMID 29365051Summary
- ASJ Treatment of Nasal Deviation With Underlying Bony Asymmetry Secondary to Augmentation Rhinoplasty in Asian PatientsLee PC, Chang RH, Chang YL2018PMID 29394321Summary
- APS An Alternative Rhinoplasty Technique: Rotational Spreader Flap ("Rabbit Flap")Sirin AA, Erdim I, Erdur O et al.2018PMID 29124376Summary
- APS 2018PMID 29380021
- APS Ethnic Rhinoplasty in Female Patients: The Neoclassical Canons RevisitedSaad A, Hewett S, Nolte M et al.2018PMID 29273934Summary
- APS Response to Comments Made on "Alternative Rhinoplasty Technique: Rotational Spreader Flap (Rabbit Flap)"Sirin AA, Erdim I2018PMID 29392358