Journal archive · Complications and management · 2023
Reducing Postoperative Swelling, Edema, and Ecchymosis after Open Rhinoplasty Using Intranasal Drainage
Haack S, Mann S, Gahl B, Haug M.
What this paper says
Placing drains under the lifted skin after open rhinoplasty significantly reduced bruising at both day 2 and day 14, and reduced swelling at day 2 only.
Overview
Blood collecting under the skin after rhinoplasty spreads into the tissue layers and produces bruising and swelling. One strategy is to drain that blood before it infiltrates. The authors used drains in open rhinoplasty performed with wide degloving, meaning the skin is lifted broadly off the nasal framework, and measured bruising, swelling and general puffiness at two time points.
Sections of note
- Setting: open rhinoplasty with wide degloving, using intranasal drains.
- Bruising was significantly reduced at day 2, p equal to 0.006, and at day 14, p equal to 0.017.
- Swelling was significantly reduced at day 2: edema p equal to 0.027 and general swelling p equal to 0.004.
- For edema and general swelling, the effect did not reach significance at day 14.
- The authors describe the method as easily applicable, cheap and reproducible.
- The abstract states the long term effect still needs to be assessed.
- No patient numbers, study design, group sizes or drain specifications appear in the abstract.
What it means for a patient
- Drains reduced visible bruising in the first two weeks, which is the period most patients care about for returning to public view.
- The swelling benefit was measurable at day 2 but had faded by day 14, so drains appear to shorten the early swelling rather than the total swelling.
- Limits are significant: the abstract gives no sample size, no description of how patients were assigned to drains, and no complication data for the drains themselves.
- The technique was studied specifically with wide degloving. Whether it helps after more limited dissection is not addressed.
Why this paper matters
Bruising and swelling are the main complaints during the first weeks after rhinoplasty and are what determine when a patient can go back to work. Drains are cheap and require no new equipment. The unanswered questions are whether they affect the final result at all and whether they carry any infection risk.
Terms
- Open rhinoplasty: nose surgery through an external incision on the strip between the nostrils.
- Degloving: lifting the skin and soft tissue off the underlying nasal framework.
- Ecchymosis: bruising, the discoloration from blood under the skin.
- Edema: swelling caused by fluid collecting in tissue.
- Drain: a small tube left in place to let blood or fluid escape rather than pool.
- Soft-tissue envelope: the skin and layers beneath it that cover the nose.
Summary written by rhinoplasty.cc from the abstract, 2026-09-09; not medical advice. The authors' own abstract follows.
From the abstract
“Reducing postoperative strain on the patient after rhinoplasty is an important goal for the surgeon. Many strategies are described to reach that goal. One strategy is to remove blood from under the dissected soft tissue envelope by drains, before it can infiltrate the different layers causing ecchymosis, edema, and…”
Excerpt; the full abstract is on PubMed.
Citation
Start here
What the rhinoplasty literature says on this paper's topic, cited line by line to PubMed.
Related papers
Same topic, 2023.
- ASJ Analysis of the Cause of Cartilage Warping in the Rhinoplasty of Costal Cartilage and Application of Embed-In Graft in Revisional SurgeryXu Y, Zhang X, You J et al.2023PMID 36656674Summary
- ASJ 2023PMID 36793242
- ASJ 2023PMID 36004498
- ASJ X-shaped Tip Graft: A Versatile Solution for Warping Correction in Rib Cartilage-Based RhinoplastyWu L, You J, Wang H et al.2023PMID 35748855Summary
- APS A Comparison Between Piezosurgery and Conventional Osteotomies in Rhinoplasty on Post-Operative Oedema and Ecchymosis: A Systematic ReviewKisel J, Khatib M, Cavale N2023PMID 36163553Summary
- APS A Perioperative Disinfection and Caring Procedure to Prevent Infection After RhinoplastyAn Y, Wang G, Zhen Y2023PMID 37286843Full text
- APS Complications Associated with Autologous Costal Cartilage Used in Rhinoplasty: An Updated Meta-AnalysisChen H, Wang X, Deng Y2023PMID 36071242Summary
- APS Defining Our Terms: Are Postoperative Complications Adequately Defined in the Rhinoplasty Literature?Oleck NC, Cason RW, Hernandez JA et al.2023PMID 36307563Summary