rhinoplasty.cc
Menu

Journal archive · Revision and secondary rhinoplasty · Rib, ear and septal grafts · 2019

FPS Facial Plastic Surgery · 2019

Current Practical Concepts for Using Rib in Secondary Rhinoplasty

Robotti E, Penna WB.

What this paper says

A review of how to harvest and work with rib cartilage in revision rhinoplasty, arguing the aim is a natural well-proportioned nose rather than one bulked out with grafts.

Overview

The article traces how rhinoplasty thinking has shifted over recent decades toward preserving structure in first operations and rebuilding it in second ones. Rib is the main material for that rebuilding. This piece covers the concepts and practical details of harvesting rib and shaping it.

Sections of note

  • Secondary rhinoplasty is described as more complex than primary rhinoplasty, itself called the most demanding facial plastic procedure.
  • The authors describe a steady shift toward maintaining structure in primary rhinoplasty and rebuilding it in secondary procedures.
  • The stated goal is no longer a small, thin, pointy nose but a well-proportioned, natural, elegant nose that breathes well.
  • Rib is described as an essential tool in many secondary procedures.
  • The named risk to avoid is a bulky nose stuffed with grafts.
  • The article covers guiding concepts and specific nuances of harvesting rib and working with it.
  • No patient numbers, complication rates, outcomes, or follow-up are reported in the abstract.

What it means for a patient

  • Revision surgery generally needs cartilage from the rib because the septum has already been used.
  • The stated target is a nose that looks unoperated, not one made as small as possible.
  • Overusing grafts produces a heavy, bulky result, which is the failure mode the authors warn against.
  • This is a review of expert practice with no measured outcomes, so it reports no results or complication rates.

Why this paper matters

Rib grafting is what makes major revision possible, and its technical details determine whether the result looks natural or overbuilt. Documenting the shift in aesthetic goals is as substantive as the technical content. The abstract offers no evidence on harvest complications or long-term graft behavior.

Terms

  • Secondary rhinoplasty: An operation on a nose already operated on.
  • Costal or rib cartilage: The cartilage joining the ribs to the breastbone, used as a graft source.
  • Structure preservation: Keeping the nasal framework intact rather than removing it.
  • Primary rhinoplasty: A patient's first nose operation.
  • Graft: A piece of tissue moved to add shape or support.

Summary written by rhinoplasty.cc from the abstract, 2026-09-09; not medical advice. The authors' own abstract follows.

From the abstract

“Rhinoplasty is universally considered as the most demanding procedure in facial plastic surgery. Secondary rhinoplasty is its crown jewel, even more complex, and likewise highly fascinating. The evolution of thought and practice in rhinoplasty in the last decades has been quick and steady, progressively acknowledging…”

Excerpt; the full abstract is on PubMed.

Citation

PubMed
Journal
Facial Plastic Surgery
Year
2019
Authors
2
Type
Journal Article, Video-Audio Media
Access
Subscription
On this site
Summary and abstract

Start here

What the rhinoplasty literature says on this paper's topics, cited line by line to PubMed.

Related papers

Same topic, 2019.

  1. ASJ
    2019PMID 30380010Summary
  2. ASJ
    2019PMID 31329818Summary
  3. ASJ
    2019PMID 30517591Summary
  4. APS
    2019PMID 30868305Summary
  5. APS
    2019PMID 31139910Summary
  6. FPS
    2019PMID 30388718Summary
  7. FPS
    2019PMID 31307095Summary
  8. FPS
    2019PMID 31639871Summary