Journal archive · Nasal tip · Open versus closed approach · 2022
Improving Projection of the Nasal Tip in Primary Endonasal Rhinoplasty
Pastorek N, Cleveland P.
What this paper says
A technique article arguing that the classic sign of inadequate tip projection, the polly beak deformity, arose from early techniques ignoring the structure and position of the tip cartilages.
Overview
The authors state that gaining, improving and maintaining tip projection is one of the essential elements of successful endonasal rhinoplasty. Early technique consisted of removing the upper margin of the tip cartilages from inside, reducing the cartilage and bone hump, and cutting the nasal bones. Some of those simple operations still look good decades later, while many are conspicuous for lacking tip projection.
Sections of note
- Technique article; the abstract reports no patient numbers, no outcomes, no complication rates and no follow up.
- The polly beak deformity is described as the hallmark of inadequate tip projection after rhinoplasty.
- Early technique is described as intracartilaginous excision of the upper margin of the lower lateral cartilages, hump reduction and bone cuts.
- The authors attribute inconsistent results to inattention to the structural integrity and anatomical position of the lower lateral cartilages.
- The senior author uses a combination of suture, strut and cartilage grafting techniques.
- Those are tailored to each patient's individual anatomy.
What it means for a patient
- Polly beak refers to a fullness above the tip that makes the profile look beak like, and it usually reflects a tip that sits too low rather than a bridge that is too high.
- Modern technique supports the tip cartilages rather than only trimming them.
- This is expert opinion and historical account. No results are reported.
Why this paper matters
Loss of tip projection was the recurring failure of early reduction rhinoplasty and drove the shift toward structural support. This article traces that history and describes the corrective approach. It provides no data on how often the described techniques succeed.
Terms
- Tip projection: how far the tip of the nose stands out from the face.
- Polly beak deformity: a fullness above the tip giving the profile a beak like outline.
- Lower lateral cartilages: the paired cartilages forming the nasal tip.
- Endonasal rhinoplasty: surgery through incisions inside the nose only.
- Intracartilaginous excision: cutting through and removing part of a cartilage from within.
Summary written by rhinoplasty.cc from the abstract, 2026-09-09; not medical advice. The authors' own abstract follows.
From the abstract
“Gaining, improving, and maintaining nasal tip projection is one of the most essential elements of successful endonasal rhinoplasty. For years the hallmark of inadequate nasal tip projection following rhinoplasty has been the Polly beak deformity. Early rhinoplasty technique consisted of intracartilaginous excision of…”
Excerpt; the full abstract is on PubMed.
Citation
Start here
What the rhinoplasty literature says on this paper's topics, cited line by line to PubMed.
Nasal tip
200 papers on this topic.
Open versus closed approach
57 papers on this topic.
Related papers
Same topic, 2022.
- ASJ Evolution of the Septal Extension Graft in Endonasal Rhinoplasty: Long-term Efficacy and ReliabilityHarel M, Shir-Az O, Berl A et al.2022PMID 35554489Summary
- APS 2022PMID 36323964
- APS Fine-Tuning of the Supratip in Rhinoplasty: An External ApproachKucukguven A, Konas E2022PMID 36042029Summary
- APS Publisher Correction: Fine-Tuning of the Supratip in Rhinoplasty: An External ApproachKucukguven A, Konas E2022PMID 36197466
- CPS The Principles and Practice of Endonasal Rhinoplasty: Special Topics for Clinics in Plastic Surgery JournalRad AN, Bridges MA, Constantian MB2022PMID 34782138Summary
- FPS 2022PMID 34500488Summary
- FPS Change in Columellar-Philtral and Nasolabial Angles Over Time Following RhinoplastyBrennan TE, Trujillo O, Sina M et al.2022PMID 35130565Summary
- FPS Grafts in Endonasal RhinoplastyLee DD, Katrib Z, Williams EF2022PMID 34024040Summary