Journal archive · Open versus closed approach · 2022
The Principles and Practice of Endonasal Rhinoplasty: Special Topics for Clinics in Plastic Surgery Journal
Rad AN, Bridges MA, Constantian MB.
What this paper says
Constantian's review of closed rhinoplasty argues that limiting dissection and recognising four common anatomical variants before surgery prevents the three patterns of secondary deformity.
Overview
This is a principles review by Mark Constantian, a long-standing advocate of endonasal rhinoplasty, with co-authors. It defines endonasal rhinoplasty as improvement through intranasal incisions only, without a transcolumellar cut, with limited soft-tissue and skeletal disruption. No patient data are given in the abstract.
Sections of note
- Dissection is intentionally limited to reduce skin contraction and scar contracture.
- Four common anatomical variants are said to predictably produce all three patterns of secondary deformity; the surgeon must identify and correct them preoperatively.
- Respecting these principles is said to increase predictability and reduce dissatisfaction and reoperation.
What it means for a patient
- In this school of thought, most bad results come from a few unrecognised anatomical starting points, not from the approach itself.
- Less dissection means less swelling and less unpredictable scarring.
- The review states principles; it does not present outcomes.
Why this paper matters
It is a concise statement of the Constantian philosophy that underlies much closed and preservation thinking. Limits: expert review, no data, the four variants are not named in the abstract.
Terms
- Endonasal rhinoplasty: all incisions inside the nose.
- Transcolumellar incision: the external cut used in open rhinoplasty.
- Secondary deformity: a problem that appears after healing and may need revision.
- Scar contracture: tightening of scar tissue that distorts shape over months.
Summary written by rhinoplasty.cc from the abstract, 2026-09-08; not medical advice. The authors' own abstract follows.
From the abstract
“Endonasal rhinoplasty is a minimally invasive approach in which esthetic and functional improvements are made solely through intranasal, without transcolumellar, incisions and with limited soft tissue and skeletal disruption. In addition to intentionally limiting surgical dissection, the rhinoplasty surgeon must…”
Excerpt; the full abstract is on PubMed.
Citation
Start here
What the rhinoplasty literature says on this paper's topic, cited line by line to PubMed.
Related papers
Same topic, 2022.
- ASJ Evolution of the Septal Extension Graft in Endonasal Rhinoplasty: Long-term Efficacy and ReliabilityHarel M, Shir-Az O, Berl A et al.2022PMID 35554489Summary
- APS 2022PMID 36323964
- APS Fine-Tuning of the Supratip in Rhinoplasty: An External ApproachKucukguven A, Konas E2022PMID 36042029Summary
- APS Publisher Correction: Fine-Tuning of the Supratip in Rhinoplasty: An External ApproachKucukguven A, Konas E2022PMID 36197466
- FPS 2022PMID 34500488Summary
- FPS Grafts in Endonasal RhinoplastyLee DD, Katrib Z, Williams EF2022PMID 34024040Summary
- FPS Improving Projection of the Nasal Tip in Primary Endonasal RhinoplastyPastorek N, Cleveland P2022PMID 34704240Summary
- FPS In-office Endonasal Minor Revision RhinoplastyAuger SR, Shah AR2022PMID 34544174Summary