Journal archive · Preservation rhinoplasty · Dorsum and hump · 2023
Precision Segmental Preservation Rhinoplasty: Avoiding Widening, Defining New Dorsal Esthetic Lines in Dorsal Preservation Rhinoplasty
Neves JC, Erol O, Arancibia-Tagle D, Ilhan E.
What this paper says
An article stating that the rapid spread of preservation rhinoplasty produced a considerable share of drawbacks and complications, causing many surgeons to return to conventional techniques, and presenting strategies to extend preservation to noses previously ruled out.
Overview
The authors describe worldwide enthusiasm driving a rapid increase in preservation surgery, accompanied by drawbacks and complications that led many surgeons to recoil and go back to classic removal techniques. Against that background they develop concepts intended to allow preservation in noses previously considered absolute contraindications.
Sections of note
- Technique and concept article; the abstract reports no patient numbers, no complication rates and no follow up.
- The authors state the rapid increase in preservation surgery promoted a considerable percentage of drawbacks and complications.
- Many surgeons are stated to have returned to classic resective techniques as a result.
- Presented strategies include redefining new dorsal aesthetic lines.
- Others are controlling the nasal side wall and the groove between nose and face.
- Avoiding widening of the middle vault is a further stated strategy.
- Precision in designing the bony and cartilaginous profile, avoiding irregularities, is also presented.
What it means for a patient
- The article's premise is that preservation rhinoplasty has a real complication burden, stated by advocates of the technique themselves.
- Widening of the middle of the nose is one of its characteristic problems and is a focus here.
- The proposed strategies aim to extend the technique to noses that were previously excluded from it.
- No results, rates or comparisons are reported.
Why this paper matters
Preservation rhinoplasty spread faster than its evidence, and this article documents the resulting retreat by some surgeons. It proposes refinements rather than defending the technique unqualified. Whether the proposed strategies reduce the named drawbacks has not been measured.
Terms
- Preservation rhinoplasty: keeping and repositioning existing structures rather than removing and rebuilding.
- Resective technique: surgery that removes tissue, here the hump.
- Dorsal aesthetic lines: the two shadow lines running down the bridge from the brows to the tip.
- Midvault widening: the middle third of the nose becoming broader after surgery.
- Nasofacial groove: the crease where the side of the nose meets the cheek.
- Contraindication: a reason a particular technique should not be used in a given patient.
Summary written by rhinoplasty.cc from the abstract, 2026-09-09; not medical advice. The authors' own abstract follows.
From the abstract
“Experiencing great worldwide scientific excitement, the number of nose preservation surgeries has increased rapidly, promoting a considerable percentage of drawbacks and complications, causing many surgeons to recoil and return to classic resective techniques. In this study, we develop concepts that allow us to…”
Excerpt; the full abstract is on PubMed.
Citation
Start here
What the rhinoplasty literature says on this paper's topics, cited line by line to PubMed.
Preservation rhinoplasty
193 papers on this topic.
Dorsum and hump
227 papers on this topic.
Related papers
Same topic, 2023.
- ASJ Advanced Preservation Rhinoplasty in the Era of Osteoplasty and Chondroplasty: How Have We Moved Beyond the Cottle Technique?Ferreira MG, Toriumi DM, Stubenitsky B et al.2023PMID 37338117Summary
- ASJ An Anatomic Analysis of the Bony Vault: From the Perspective of Osteotomy in RhinoplastyKim SJ, Kim TH, Lee KH2023PMID 36594157Summary
- ASJ 2023PMID 37707591
- ASJ Commentary on: An Anatomic Analysis of the Bony Vault: From the Perspective of Osteotomy in RhinoplastySalehi PP, Frants A, Nassif PS2023PMID 36752982
- ASJ Nasal Bones Anatomy and Analysis for Dorsal Preservation RhinoplastyFonseca E, Baldini N, Alomani M et al.2023PMID 36402140Full text
- ASJ Transection of Pitanguy's Midline Ligament to Avoid Supratip Depression in Closed-Approach, Low-Septal-Resection Dorsal Preservation RhinoplastyErdal AI, Genç İG2023PMID 35908175Summary
- APS A Comparison Between Piezosurgery and Conventional Osteotomies in Rhinoplasty on Post-Operative Oedema and Ecchymosis: A Systematic ReviewKisel J, Khatib M, Cavale N2023PMID 36163553Summary
- APS A Systematic Analysis of the Nasal Septum in Crooked Noses and Suggested Treatment Algorithm According to Preservation Rhinoplasty (PR) PrinciplesTremp M, Schneider J, Raghu RBN et al.2023PMID 36826521Summary